Re: colorsync-users Digest, Vol 20, Issue 25
Andrew and Andrew... Thanks for your responses. (My internet has been down for 3 days and I just switched to a new carrier, so please pardon my delay in responding.) I suspect editing for "pleasing results" is probably the most sensible approach. I like my initial WB to be reasonably close, mainly as a point of departure. When editing and staring at the monitor for a while, it's very easy for my eyes to adapt to the displayed image and fool me into thinking my edits look good, when in fact they are not. When coming back to revisit an image after some time away from my computer, problems with color, saturation, brightness and contrast often slap me in the face. Defeating "eye adaptation" has always been my biggest challenge, so getting WB close initially helps. That is what prompted my question. I find that using some sort of reference (white card, gray card, Color Checker, etc) can help, but I also find that forcing those neutral patches to be truly neutral often results in a WB that that seems to disagree somewhat with what "I think" my mind remembers. I suspect our eyes pick a WB that lays somewhere in between AWB that camera suggests and forcing a gray card to be perfectly neutral. So, I was hoping to learn more about how our visual system "white balances" a scene. If I am photographing a portrait in the woods under a canopy a green leaves, a gray card works very well. I want the skin tones to be accurate so the person doesn't look sickly greenish yellow, and the rest of the scene is less critical. But, if the scene is of the woods themselves, I find that a gray card often results in overcompensation. Anyway, thanks for your responses. Color is complicated. Lou
On Nov 18, 2023, at 7:04 PM, Louis Dina via colorsync-users <colorsync-users@lists.apple.com> wrote:
So, I was hoping to learn more about how our visual system "white balances" a scene.
Very differently than a camera! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromatic_adaptation From the superb Color Primer by Fred Bunting (still a must-have reference decades after being written): "Chromatic Adaptation The term chromatic adaptation, sometimes known as color consistency, refers to the remarkable ability of our visual system to adjust the white point for a scene so that colors appear the same independent of the color temperature of the illumination. The color of an object does not appear to change from indoor fluorescent light to daylight. This is such a common visual experience that we take it for granted. Chromatic adaptation can be a significant issue for color matching in graphic arts. The white point of a monitor and the white of a paper stock may be quite different. Although taken individually, the eye will see each as white. Side by side, the monitor’s white may look rather blue in comparison to the paper’s."
participants (2)
-
Andrew Rodney
-
Louis Dina