alloc in Swift
alloc in Swift
- Subject: alloc in Swift
- From: Mike Ellard <email@hidden>
- Date: Fri, 13 Feb 2015 12:17:48 -0800
I was exploring the NSObject documentation for Swift and I was surprised to see that alloc is callable in Swift.
I was even more surprised when I did some tests to see how it functions. Here’s some code, taken from a Playground: class SomeClass: NSObject { override class func alloc() -> SomeClass { println("I'm alloc-ing!") return super.alloc() as! SomeClass println("** Checkpoint 1 **") let x = SomeClass.alloc() println("** Checkpoint 2 **") println("** Checkpoint 3 **")
What this code shows you when you run it is that:
1) You can use alloc to create an object that completely bypasses your Swift initializer(s), and which has garbage (zero) values for all of its properties. You can do this whether or not you override alloc. Once created, it does not appear that there is any way to run an initializer on this object.
2) If you override alloc and you do use your Swift initializer, your override of alloc is *not* called.
3) If you use `new`, then both alloc and your Swift initializer are called.
What I would expect:
A) Swift would not expose alloc or `new` at all. There shouldn’t be a way to create objects without going through an initializer. B) If a class does override alloc (either in Swift in or a mixed Objective-C / Swift project), then initializing an object would call the overridden alloc method. C) That in Swift, the NSObject alloc method would be “final” so that it couldn’t be overridden.
From this, I have two questions:
First, what is the purpose of exposing alloc and `new` in Swift? It seems like a great way for people to get in trouble and/or develop bad habits.
Second, is the behavior of bypassing an alloc override expected when using a Swift initializer on a class that inherits from NSObject?
Thanks for any insight that you can give me on this. I’ve also filed Radars 19830482, 19830571 and 19830767.
Sincerely,
Michael Patrick Ellard
|
_______________________________________________
Do not post admin requests to the list. They will be ignored.
Xcode-users mailing list (email@hidden)
Help/Unsubscribe/Update your Subscription:
This email sent to email@hidden