I've been hearing this, literally, since System 7 DARED introduce "cloyingly charming" uselessness like color into the UI.
or the end of the world when Mac OS 8 changed the UI more.
and the end of the world when the apple logo was in the middle of the screen in the OS X public beta.
I've ignored it all, because one thing my experience in the Apple world has taught me is this:
Apple users only like change when it happens to someone else. Gore their ox, and let the screaming begin.
It's like AppleScript. No matter how often Apple improves it, and updates it, it's always about to die because <my personal beef> wasn't fixed.
It's all silliness. Just because you, or I don't like a thing doesn't make that thing actually broken.